Most people in their forties notice something shifting. The usual explanation is hormones, and that is part of it. But a 2024 study found something that complicates the story, and it is worth knowing about.
The short answer
Several things change at once: collagen, thickness, lipid production, turnover rate. In women, falling estrogen accelerates much of it, and the numbers are larger than most people expect. But aging does not appear to be a steady slope, and the mid-forties shift shows up in men as well, which means hormones are not the whole explanation.
What is physically changing
Start with the structure, because this is the part that is well established.
Collagen declines. Types I and III, the structural proteins that give skin its firmness.
Skin thins. Measurably, and the rate is quantified below.
Lipid production falls. Which matters because, as I wrote recently, the lipid matrix between cells is what does the sealing. Less mortar, same bricks.
Turnover slows. Cells take longer to move up and shed, which changes surface texture.
The estrogen numbers, which are bigger than people think
For women, menopause is not a gentle contributor to this. It is a steep one, and the published figures are specific.
Around 30 percent of skin collagen, types I and III, is reported lost in the first five years after menopause.1
After that it continues at roughly 2 percent per postmenopausal year, with skin thickness falling about 1.13 percent per year.1
And the detail I find most striking: those declines track more closely with how long someone has been estrogen deficient than with their chronological age.1
That last point reframes the whole question. Two women the same age can be in quite different places depending on when their menopause began. “After 40” is a convenient label, not a biological boundary.
Then the 2024 study complicated it
A group at Stanford tracked more than 135,000 molecules and microbes across 108 people aged 25 to 75, including transcripts, proteins, metabolites, lipids and the skin microbiome.2
They were looking for a steady slope. They did not find one. What they found were two periods where molecular profiles shifted substantially more than the surrounding years, centered on roughly age 44 and age 60.
The researchers assumed the mid-forties wave was perimenopause. Then they looked at the men, and found the same thing.
That is the finding worth sitting with, especially if you are a woman who has been told that everything happening to you after 40 is hormonal.
The first author, Xiaotao Shen, put it carefully: menopause and perimenopause may contribute to what is seen in women in their mid-forties, but there are likely other and more significant factors affecting both men and women. Among the molecules changing most in that window were ones involved in lipid metabolism and in the metabolism of alcohol and caffeine.
What that study does not say
This one travelled a long way in the press, and it picked up some things along the way that are not in the paper. Apply the questions from the research article.
✗ It is not “you age in two bursts.” It found molecular profiles changing nonlinearly. That is not the same as a person visibly aging overnight at a birthday.
✗ Nobody was followed from 43 to 45. Participants were tracked for a median of about 1.7 years. The waves come from comparing people of different ages, not from watching individuals cross those thresholds.
✗ It is 108 people. Rich data on a small cohort. Genuinely interesting, not yet settled.
✗ Molecules are not symptoms. A shift in a metabolite is not a wrinkle, and the study does not claim it is.
None of that makes it a bad study. It is a careful piece of work that says something genuinely new about the shape of aging. It just does not say the thing the headlines said.
What this does not license me to say
A note about my own position, because this is the article where I am closest to my own customers.
Most of the people who buy from me are women over 40. Everything above would be convenient marketing material, and I want to be clear about what it does not permit.
Collagen decline, skin thinning and lipid production are physiological processes. A cosmetic acts on appearance. So none of this evidence lets me say my products address collagen loss, restore anything, or do something about the mid-forties wave. It does not, I have not tested it, and the biology being real does not transfer to a product by proximity.
Worth saying plainly
If anything in skincare marketing genuinely reversed collagen loss, it would not be a cosmetic. It would be a drug, and it would be regulated as one. That is the clearest test available to a reader, and it costs nothing to apply.
Where to take this
I am a formulation scientist, not a physician, so I will stay in my lane. There is a real clinical literature on hormonal change and skin, including on what hormone therapy does and does not do, and those are questions for a doctor who knows your history rather than for a skincare company. If what you are noticing is bothering you, that is the conversation worth having, and it is a more useful one than anything a jar can offer.
✗ The myth
“Everything that changes about my skin after 40 is menopause.”
✓ The fact
Estrogen loss is a major and well quantified factor. It is not the only one, and the mid-forties molecular shift appears in men too.
Key takeaways
✓ Collagen, thickness, lipid production and turnover all change, and they change together.
✓ Around 30 percent of skin collagen is reported lost in the first five years after menopause, then roughly 2 percent a year.
✓ Those declines track the duration of estrogen deficiency more closely than chronological age, so “after 40” is a label rather than a threshold.
✓ A 2024 multi-omics study found molecular change clustering around ages 44 and 60 rather than following a steady slope.
✓ The researchers expected the mid-forties wave to be perimenopause. It appeared in men as well.
✓ 108 people, median 1.7 years of follow-up, molecular profiles rather than symptoms. Interesting, not settled.
References
Links go to the peer-reviewed record. You are welcome to check my work.
1. Effect of estrogens on skin aging and the potential role of SERMs. Clin Interv Aging. Reviews the reported 30 percent collagen loss in the first five postmenopausal years, the subsequent 2 percent per year, and the 1.13 percent annual decline in skin thickness. PMC2685269
2. Shen X, Wang C, Zhou X, Zhou W, Hornburg D, Wu S, Snyder MP. Nonlinear dynamics of multi-omics profiles during human aging. Nat Aging. 2024. doi:10.1038/s43587-024-00692-2
3. Skin, hair and beyond: the impact of menopause. Climacteric. 2022. doi:10.1080/13697137.2022.2050206
4. van Smeden J, Janssens M, Gooris GS, Bouwstra JA. The important role of stratum corneum lipids for the cutaneous barrier function. Biochim Biophys Acta. 2014;1841(3):295–313. ScienceDirect
Still have a question?
Submit it here, and it may become the next Ask the Scientist article.
About the author
Dr. Farzaneh Rezaei, PhD, Microbial Formulation Scientist
Founder of Fafabiotic, with two decades developing microbial technologies. She writes Ask the Scientist to explain the science behind probiotic skincare without the marketing layer.
Educational content only. This article is not medical advice and is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure or prevent any disease.
