Greetings, skin microbiome enthusiasts,
In September 2026, three big beauty brands launched the same eye patch, in the same package, within days of each other. It’s a perfect example of something most shoppers never see: who actually makes the skincare they buy.
In this post, I’ll explain what happened, why it keeps happening in beauty, and why we decided not to launch Fafabiotic the way most skincare brands do.
What happened with the eye patches?
Fenty Skin, Glow Recipe and Huda Beauty each revealed under-eye patches in nearly identical twist-to-slice packaging, in quick succession (Cosmetics Business). A French trade outlet counted five brands launching the same packaging within days (La Réclame). Korean brand Wonder Bath had already launched the same self-slicing format that July (Hypebae).
Huda Kattan said each brand had been told by the same packaging supplier that it had exclusivity (Marketing-Interactive). There is no public confirmation that all three used the same manufacturer (T2 Online). And all three brands said the formulas inside are different (ASI Central).
Same package, different products. Keep that in mind.
Why do so many skincare products look alike?
Because many brands start from the same place.
Shared factories. Many beauty brands don’t make their own products. Korea’s top four contract manufacturers alone serve more than 10,000 brand clients (KoreaProductPost). Many smaller brands own a label but no factory, and rely on these partners from formulation through production (Korea JoongAng Daily).
Shared packaging. Experts note that shared suppliers and stock packaging can lead brands to similar products without anyone copying (Hypebae).
Long shelf life expectations. Products are built to last. In Europe, a product that lasts 30 months or less must print a use-by date (Cosmetics & Toiletries).
When brands draw from the same manufacturers, trends and platforms, similar ideas reach the market at once (BeautyMatter).
Why Fafabiotic took a different path
I’m a microbial formulation scientist, and I’ve spent my career working with living microbes. When I set out to bring that science into skincare, I wanted live cells in the bottle, not just a probiotic name on the label.
So I went to the manufacturers that other brands work with. They weren’t able to help me. Their systems are built for formulas that stay the same on a shelf for years. A living probiotic needs to be protected, kept dormant, and woken up at the right moment.
In-house, with a formula we own 100%
So we brought everything in-house, including our formulation.
What surprised me most along the way: not every brand owns 100% of its formula. Many work with those same manufacturers and choose a variation of what is already doable there. Our concept wasn’t just a variation of what already existed, so we needed to do it our way.
To be clear about Fafabiotic:
- We own 100% of our formulation.
- It is not white-labeled.
- It was not developed by someone else and just tested by us.
- We make it ourselves, in small, fresh batches.
You can read more about the science behind our live-cell approach on our Science page.
What this means for you
- You activate it. The live probiotic stays dormant and separate until you activate it at home, right before first use.
- Fresh, not stored. We make small batches instead of huge runs meant to sit in warehouses.
- An honest label. Our formula is stable for two years, but we label every bottle for one year, to be extra careful.
- One simple step. One lotion, morning and night, with no crowded shelf.
The eye patches had the same package and different formulas inside. We went the other way: our packaging, process and formula were built together, for something alive. Curious what that looks like on real skin? See the before-and-after photos customers have shared.
Questions to ask about any skincare you buy
- Who developed this formula? The brand, or a manufacturer that also makes products for others?
- Where is it made? In-house, or at a contract manufacturer?
- What makes it different inside the bottle, not just on the outside?
- If it says “probiotic,” are the cells live, or is it a ferment or lysate? Both can be useful, but they are not the same.
- How long is it meant to sit on a shelf, and why?
Many brands will happily answer. And if a brand can’t tell you who made its formula, that tells you something too.
Ready to try skincare that’s made differently?
Until next blog,
Cheers
Sources
- Cosmetics Business: beauty’s “eye patch gate”
- La Réclame: lessons from the beauty drama (French)
- Hypebae: eye patch packaging explainer
- Marketing-Interactive: beauty’s packaging déjà vu
- T2 Online: who did it first?
- ASI Central: packaging mishap
- BeautyMatter: who will own the grinder eye patch?
- KoreaProductPost: Korean ODMs surpass 10,000 clients
- Korea JoongAng Daily: Kolmar and Cosmax record Q2
- Cosmetics & Toiletries: EU minimum durability rules
