What Does Fermentation Actually Do?

Fermented is one of the most common words on a skincare label and one of the least informative. It tells you something happened to an ingredient. It does not tell you what came out the other end.

The short answer

Microorganisms metabolize a substrate and change it. They break large molecules into smaller ones, release compounds that were bound up in the material, and produce new ones that were not there before. All of that is real. What it does not do is tell you which of those things happened in the bottle you are holding.

What is actually going on

Fermentation is microorganisms eating something and leaving the leftovers.

That sounds reductive, but it is the whole mechanism. You give a culture a substrate, which might be rice, soy, kelp, milk, wheat bran or almost anything else. The organisms consume parts of it to live. In doing so they break molecules apart, release things that were locked inside the material, and secrete products of their own metabolism. What you harvest afterwards is chemically different from what you started with.

What typically comes out

Smaller molecules. Large structures in the substrate get broken down, and compounds that were bound inside the material become free.1

Organic acids. Malic, fumaric, citric, lactic. These are ordinary metabolic products and some are familiar cosmetic ingredients in their own right.1

Amino acids, peptides, proteins. Both from breaking down the substrate and from the organisms themselves.2

Entirely new molecules. Some organisms make things the substrate never contained. Hyaluronic acid can be produced this way, and the molecular weight can be controlled by how the process is run.1

None of that is marketing. It is a well described set of changes, and it is why the technique is interesting to a formulator.

The problem is that it is a process, not a result

Here is the gap between the word and the information.

“Fermented” on a label is like “cooked” on a menu. It describes something that was done. It says nothing about what was cooked, by what method, for how long, or whether the result is any good. Four variables decide the outcome, and the label usually tells you at most one of them.

1.  Which organism. A yeast and a lactic acid bacterium metabolize differently and leave different things behind.

2.  Which substrate. The starting material determines what is available to break down and release.

3.  The conditions. Temperature, pH, oxygen, duration. Stopping a ferment at two days and at ten days gives you two different ingredients.

4.  What happens afterwards. Filtered, lysed, extracted, concentrated. As I wrote in the postbiotic article, a filtrate has had the cells removed and a lysate has had them broken open. Same ferment, different ingredient.

Two products can both say fermented and share nothing else at all.

Which makes the evidence question interesting

I want to be fair here, because some fermented ingredients have genuinely good data behind them and I do not want this read as dismissal.

Galactomyces ferment filtrate is the strongest example. There is human work, not just cell culture. A four-week study in 104 participants reported reductions in facial redness, roughness and pore appearance, and there is a longitudinal study reporting cumulative changes in hydration, water loss and the appearance of wrinkles, spots and roughness over a twelve-month treatment period.3 There is also laboratory work on how it affects gene expression in skin cells.4

That is a real evidence base. Worth noting, in the spirit of the article on reading studies, that a good share of it comes from work connected to the ingredient’s commercial owner. That is not disqualifying and it is extremely common. It is a reason to read the methods rather than the headline.

Now compare. Bifida ferment lysate is one of the most heavily marketed fermented ingredients in skincare. Looking for human trials on it, what I mostly find is cell culture work: effects on barrier gene expression and on inflammatory signaling in cultured cells.5 Interesting, and a different tier of evidence entirely.

The point

Evidence for one ferment is not evidence for fermentation. A twelve-month study on a particular yeast filtrate says something about that filtrate. It says nothing about a rice ferment, a kelp ferment, or whatever is in the jar in front of you. This is the same principle as the strain article, one level up.

The claim I would want tested

The most common thing said about fermented skincare is that it absorbs better, because fermentation produces smaller molecules.

The first half is well supported. Fermentation does reduce molecular size.1 The second half is an inference, and it is the kind that needs demonstrating rather than assuming. Poor permeability through skin membranes is a recognized and persistent problem for cosmetic peptides, which is precisely the category fermentation is supposed to be solving.6 Smaller is not automatically absorbed, and “better bioavailability” is a measurable claim that should come with a measurement.

My own two ferments

My lotion contains two fermented ingredients, doing two completely unrelated jobs.

One is a sea kelp bioferment, which appears on the label as a ferment filtrate. It brings polysaccharides, which hold water. I describe it as a humectant, because that is what I can support.

The other is Lactobacillus Ferment, which is my preservative, for the reasons I set out last week.

Neither is marketed as “fermented skincare” and I would gain nothing by doing so. Both are fermented. Knowing that tells you almost nothing about either, which is rather the point of this article.

✗  The myth

“Fermented ingredients are more effective and absorb better.”

✓  The fact

Fermented ingredients are different. Whether a particular one is better is a question about that ingredient, answered by testing it, not by the word on the label.

What to ask

✓  Fermented from what, by what? Both halves. The INCI name usually gives you them if you read it carefully.

✓  Filtrate, lysate or ferment? Different things, as covered in the postbiotic article.

✓  If a study is cited, is it on this ferment? Not on fermentation, and not on a different one.

✓  What is it there to do? A ferment can be an active, a humectant or a preservative. Those are different roles and a company should know which one it bought.

Key takeaways

✓  Fermentation is microorganisms metabolizing a substrate and changing it, which is a real and well described set of chemical changes.

✓  It produces smaller molecules, organic acids, amino acids and peptides, and sometimes entirely new compounds.

✓  “Fermented” is a process word. The outcome depends on the organism, the substrate, the conditions and what was done afterwards.

✓  Some fermented ingredients have genuine human data. Galactomyces ferment filtrate is the clearest case.

✓  Evidence for one ferment is not evidence for fermentation.

✓  Smaller molecules do not automatically mean better absorption. That is a measurable claim and it should come with a measurement.

References

Links go to the peer-reviewed record. You are welcome to check my work.

1. Unlocking the potential of fermentation in cosmetics: a review. Fermentation. 2023;9(5):463. Covers breakdown of substrates into smaller molecules, release of bound compounds, organic acid production, and microbial synthesis of hyaluronic acid with controlled molecular weight. mdpi.com

2. Biological and cosmetical importance of fermented raw materials: an overview. Reports production of proteins, ceramides, amino acids and antioxidants by specific microbial strains. PMC9369470

3. Significant reversal of facial wrinkle, pigmented spot and roughness by daily application of Galactomyces ferment filtrate-containing skin products for 12 months. J Clin Med. 2023;12(3):1168. mdpi.com

4. Transcriptomic analysis of human keratinocytes treated with Galactomyces ferment filtrate. J Clin Med. 2022;11(16):4645. doi:10.3390/jcm11164645

5. Cell culture work on Bifida ferment lysate, reporting changes in barrier and antimicrobial peptide gene expression in HaCaT cells and in inflammatory signaling in THP-1 macrophages. Review summary

6. Peptides: emerging candidates for the prevention and treatment of skin senescence: a review. Identifies poor permeability through membranes as a significant limitation for cosmetic peptides. PMC11762834

Still have a question?

Submit it here, and it may become the next Ask the Scientist article.

Ask your question

About the author

Dr. Farzaneh Rezaei, PhD, Microbial Formulation Scientist

Founder of Fafabiotic, with two decades developing microbial technologies. She writes Ask the Scientist to explain the science behind probiotic skincare without the marketing layer.

More about me

Educational content only. This article is not medical advice and is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure or prevent any disease.

Share