- +1-910-939-3205
- Cary, North Carolina 27518, United States
- hello@fafabiotic.com
Most advice about reading ingredient lists is built on a rule that only half applies. Here is what the list is actually required to tell you, what it is allowed to hide, and where the useful information really sits.
The short answer
Ingredients are listed in descending order only while they are above one percent of the formula. Below that, they can be listed in any order the company likes. So the top of the list is information and the bottom of the list is arrangement.
An ingredient list is a legal document, not a description. It is written in a controlled vocabulary, it follows rules most people have never read, and it is allowed to leave things out. None of that is scandalous. It is just worth knowing before you draw conclusions from it.
Ingredient names come from a controlled vocabulary called INCI, maintained by an international nomenclature committee. US labelling rules give preference to those names, with a defined fallback order when no INCI name exists.1
This is why the same thing can look intimidating on one label and friendly on another. Tocopherol and vitamin E are the same molecule. One of them is the assigned name. That is the whole difference.
The rule everyone repeats is that ingredients appear in descending order, most abundant first. That is true, and there is an alternative permitted arrangement that changes what the bottom half means.1
21 CFR 701.3(f), in plain terms
1. Everything above one percent, in descending order of predominance.
2. Everything at one percent or less, in any order at all.
3. Color additives, in any order, at the end, regardless of how much is present.
Read group two again. Once an ingredient drops to one percent or below, its position carries no information whatsoever. A brand can put the ingredient it wants to talk about at the top of that group and the one it would rather you skim past at the bottom, and both placements are equally correct.
“Fifth ingredient on the list” sounds like a fact. Below one percent, it is a layout decision.
You cannot know exactly, but you can estimate. Certain ingredients are almost always used at or below one percent, so they act as markers. Once you hit them, assume everything after is unordered.
Common markers include xanthan gum and other thickeners, most preservatives, citric acid and other pH adjusters, fragrance, and most botanical extracts. If a list reads water, glycerin, a few oils, an emulsifier, then a run of extracts and a gum and a preservative, the line is somewhere around where the extracts begin.
Fragrance components
The regulation permits the single word in place of naming the ingredient: “except that fragrance or flavor may be listed as fragrance or flavor”.1
In practice that one word stands in for many individual fragrance components, none of which are named. That is the largest gap in any ingredient list, and it reflects how fragrances are compounded rather than anything the rule states.
“And other ingredients”
Where FDA has accepted an ingredient as exempt from public disclosure, this phrase may appear at the end in place of the name.1 Rare, but real.
Incidental ingredients
Substances present at insignificant levels with no technical or functional effect, and processing aids removed before packaging, do not have to be declared at all.1
This is my own corner of the field, so a few notes on what those entries mean.
A bare genus name, such as Lactobacillus, is often all the vocabulary allows. It does not tell you whether the organism is alive.
Ferment means something was fermented. The entry describes a process, not a state.
Ferment filtrate means the liquid left after the solids were filtered out. The cells have been removed.
Lysate means cells that were deliberately broken open. Cell components are present.
No strain designation will ever appear. INCI has no mechanism for one. If a brand knows its strain, it has to tell you somewhere else on the pack.
Concentration. Only rank order, and only above one percent.
Quality or grade. Two products can list the same name and use materials of very different purity.
Processing. How something was extracted, dried or handled changes what it does and never appears.
Whether anything in there is alive. Nothing in the format conveys viability.
✗ The myth
“The good ingredient is near the end of the list, so there is too little of it to do anything.”
✓ The fact
The first half is right. Past the one percent line, there genuinely is one percent or less of it.
The conclusion is what does not follow. Many ingredients are used at a fraction of a percent because that is the correct amount, not because a company was stingy. And within that group the order is arbitrary, so you cannot rank them against each other either.
1. Read the first five names properly. That is most of the product by weight, and that part of the order is real.
2. Find the marker ingredients and stop treating order as meaningful after them.
3. Check the hero ingredient is on there at all. Occasionally it is not.
4. Compare the list against the marketing. If the front says probiotic and the list says ferment filtrate, those disagree.
5. Then stop. The list has given you what it can. Everything else has to come from what the company is willing to publish.
Key takeaways
✓ Descending order applies only above one percent. Below that, any order is permitted.
✓ Color additives go last regardless of how much is present.
✓ One word, fragrance, may stand for a mixture of many components.
✓ Incidental ingredients and processing aids need not be declared at all.
✓ For microbial entries, filtrate means the cells were removed and lysate means they were broken open. Neither indicates anything living.
✓ The list cannot tell you concentration, quality, processing, or viability. Those come from what a company chooses to publish.
References
Links go to the primary source. You are welcome to check my work.
1. US Code of Federal Regulations, 21 CFR 701.3, Designation of ingredients. Paragraph (a) covers descending order and the fragrance and trade secret provisions. Paragraph (f) sets out the grouped alternative: above one percent in descending order, one percent or less in any order, then color additives in any order. Paragraph (l) exempts incidental ingredients and processing aids. eCFR
2. US Food and Drug Administration. Cosmetic ingredient names. fda.gov
3. US Food and Drug Administration. Cosmetics labeling guide. fda.gov
Still have a question?
Submit it here, and it may become the next Ask the Scientist article.
About the author
Dr. Farzaneh Rezaei, PhD, Microbial Formulation Scientist
Founder of Fafabiotic, with two decades developing microbial technologies. She writes Ask the Scientist to explain the science behind probiotic skincare without the marketing layer.
Educational content only. This article is not medical advice and is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure or prevent any disease.
