Greetings, skin microbiome enthusiasts.
Do we think the era of buying a beauty product because a celebrity or influencer said so is ending?
I don’t want to take anyone’s livelihood away. Creators are talented, and good video is hard to make. As a scientist, I know my content skills aren’t my strength. I would happily work with someone who can help me explain my work clearly, and they should be paid for that work.
What I struggle with is the model where someone is paid to say a product will work magic. I don’t believe any skincare works for everyone. A paid voice rarely tells you what a product can’t do, and that’s the part I most want to hear.
How my generation learned this
I think many of us in my generation learned this the hard way. When social media took off, creators talked about things we felt we were supposed to already know, and a lot of us felt behind. Some of those voices later became advertisers, and for a while, the model worked.
It still works for many people. A 2023 survey of US shoppers from a creator shopping platform found that 78% of Gen Z women see creators as their most trusted beauty source. That’s a useful data point, but the platform sells creator shopping, so it’s a view from inside that model. AgilityPR coverage of the LTK Beauty Shopper Study, 2023
What I prefer
My preference has always been different: real customers sharing their own experience. Most of my customers aren’t comfortable on camera, and I respect that. The ones who do share, I’m grateful for.
I’d also rather be asked, “What’s in it?” than “Who’s wearing it?” I want people to see the formula, the lab work, and the limits, not just the glow.
A new kind of creator for indie brands
I’d love to see creators who are passionate about discovering new products and sharing them with others. For indie brands like mine, that kind of sharing can make a real difference.
The most useful version, in my view, is a creator who shares a product within their own niche. Someone who follows microbial products and their uses in agriculture, food, fashion, or health could introduce a brand to people who are already curious about the science.
The key is being clear about what the creator knows. If they haven’t used or tested a product, and haven’t received it as a gift, they can still share the brand’s information and why it’s interesting to their community. They just need to say that plainly. The FTC’s guidance is clear that you can’t describe your personal experience with a product you haven’t tried, and that paid or affiliate relationships should be disclosed. FTC, Endorsement Guides: What People Are Asking
A simple disclosure could read:
I haven’t tried this product. I’m sharing it because it’s relevant to my community, based on the information on the brand’s science page. I earn a commission on purchases through my link.
For brands, unique codes or links make it easy to see which introductions led to sales, and to compensate creators fairly. For creators, that clarity protects their credibility with their own followers.
I think this kind of introduction can help indie brands reach people who care about the science, without asking anyone to pretend they’ve tried something they haven’t.
If you’re buying skincare online
When you can’t test a product in a store, here’s what I’d check before you buy:
- What’s in it? Is the organism or ingredient named, and is the amount stated?
- Who stands behind it? Is there a real person, and do they explain their work?
- What happens if it doesn’t work for me? Is there a clear return policy?
Do you still buy a beauty product because someone famous or paid recommended it? And if you buy skincare online, how do you decide what to trust? I’d love to hear from you in the comments.
Until next blog, cheers.
